Why You Need to Hire a Board Certified and Registered Arboricultural Consultant as an Expert Witness for Tree Expert Litigation Support, Development Projects, and Insurance Claims

 

When disputes arise over trees—whether from property damage, construction impact, negligence, or insurance claims—few professionals can offer the depth of clarity and credibility that a Board Certified and Registered Arboricultural Consultant brings. Trees are living assets that can represent a significant amenity landscape and ornamental value. When one is lost or damaged, or when questions of tree risk management emerge, the case often demands more than an opinion—it demands expert insight backed by science, experience, and professional integrity.

​

That’s where Marty Shaw of Green Season Consulting stands out. As a Board Certified Master Arborist, Registered Consulting Arborist, Author, and Expert Witness, Marty has provided expert consulting on more than 500 cases across 26 states. He has served as a trusted Expert Witness in over 30 legal cases. His deep understanding of Tree Litigation, Tree Appraisals, Land Use, Plant Appraisals, Investigations, Tree Risk Assessment, and Tree Risk Management has made him a trusted voice for attorneys, developers, insurance professionals, and landowners nationwide.

​

​

The Value of a Board Certified and Registered Arboricultural Consultant in Tree Litigation

 

Tree-related legal disputes are often far more complex than they appear. What might start as a simple disagreement about a damaged tree can quickly evolve into a high-stakes legal matter involving property rights, negligence, liability, and valuation. A Board Certified and Registered Arboricultural Consultant like Marty Shaw bridges the gap between various scientific and professional disciplines, bringing clarity to these complex cases.

​

Tree Law encompasses issues such as:

• Boundary tree disputes between neighbors

• Trespass removal of trees

• Root or branch encroachment damaging property or utilities

• Tree failures resulting in injury or death

• Construction damage to protected trees

• Emanant  domain

 

Each of these scenarios requires both technical understanding of facts and expert interpretation. Courts rely on certified and registered professionals to explain how, why, and when a tree was impacted—and what that damage means in both ecological and financial terms. Marty’s ability to translate arboricultural science and professional disciplines into language that judges and juries can understand is what gives you that critical edge.

​

​

Why Expert Witness Testimony Can Make or Break a Case

 

In any tree-related litigation, expert witness testimony can be the linchpin that determines any outcome. A Board Certified and Registered Arboricultural Expert Witness provides factual, unbiased opinions grounded in established arboricultural standards and guidance such as those set by the Tree Care Industry Association (TCIA), International Society of Arboriculture (ISA), and the Council of Tree and Landscape Appraisers (CTLA).

​

When Marty Shaw testifies, he draws on decades of experience, detailed field forensics, accurate research, precise analysis, and appropriate methodology. His testimony can include:

• Tree value assessments and appraisals

• Causation analysis for tree failures

• Examination of maintenance standards and negligence claims

• Evaluation of construction impact and soil/root disturbance

• Review of municipal or state tree protection ordinances

• Evaluation and site use assessment

• Tree risk management policy review and evaluation

 

His role is not to advocate for one side, but to speak for the science—clarifying the facts so the court can make informed, just decisions. That credibility is what makes him invaluable to attorneys seeking expert witness support in complex tree disputes.

​

​

Consulting for Attorneys: Turning Evidence into Clarity

 

For attorneys handling property, construction, or environmental cases, understanding the biological and technical details surrounding a tree’s condition or value is challenging. Marty Shaw provides pre-trial consulting that helps legal teams build cases and find helpful resources.

​

This includes:

• Reviewing discovery materials

• Conducting independent site investigations

• Preparing written expert reports within court standards

• Assisting in depositions or examinations

• Helping attorneys understand opposing expert opinions

 

In over 500 consulting cases, Marty has seen every type of tree-related claim imaginable—from multi-million-dollar development disputes to residential property conflicts. His consulting work brings clarity and confidence to legal teams navigating the intersection of law, science, and environmental responsibility.

​

​

Developers: Avoiding Costly Mistakes and Legal Exposure

 

Tree protection and landscape preservation are integral parts of contemporary land development. Whether building commercial structures, residential communities, or municipal projects, developers face strict environmental regulations and potential legal exposure related to impacts on our tree canopy.

​

Hiring a Certified Arborist Consultant early in the project can prevent costly mistakes such as:

• Damaging or removing protected trees without permits

• Failing to maintain proper tree protection zones

• Mismanaging root zones during grading or excavation

• Neglecting replanting requirements or mitigation plans

 

Marty’s consulting experience allows him to partner with developers and project managers proactively, identifying potential legal or environmental problems before they turn into violations or lawsuits. His Tree Risk Assessments and Tree

 

Preservation Plans not only ensure compliance but also safeguard a project’s reputation and long-term value.

In many cases, developers who consult with Marty save significant time and money by avoiding the need for remediation or litigation down the road.

​

​

Insurance Claims and Tree Appraisals: Determining Credible Value After Loss

 

When storms, accidents, or negligence lead to tree loss or property damage, insurance claims often hinge on reliable valuation. A Certified Arborist Consultant like Marty Shaw provides the data-driven assessments insurance adjusters, property owners, and attorneys rely on.

​

Through standardized appraisal methods, Marty determines:

• Replacement or restoration costs

• Diminution in property value

• Economic, functional, and aesthetic contributions of trees

• The cause and progression of damage

 

These Tree Appraisals, Landscape Appraisals, and Plant Appraisals give insurers and claimants an objective foundation for fair compensation. For complex claims involving multiple parties, such as damage from construction or vehicle impact, Marty’s reports often become the central reference for settlement or trial.

​

​

The Importance of Investigations and Tree Risk Assessment

 

Sometimes, the question isn’t just what happened, but why. That’s where investigative work becomes essential. Marty’s approach to Tree Risk Assessment and forensic investigation blends scientific rigor with real-world experience.

He examines factors such as:

• Root structure and soil conditions

• Decay, disease, or pest activity

• Pruning or maintenance history

• Wind exposure and site grading

• Human interference or negligence

 

By reconstructing the conditions that led to a tree’s failure or decline, Marty helps clients understand whether an event was preventable—and who, if anyone, may be responsible. His findings often inform both legal strategy and risk mitigation planning for property owners, municipalities, and insurance carriers.

​

​

National Reach, Local Understanding

 

With consulting experience in 26 states, Marty Shaw understands that Tree Governance varies by jurisdiction—and local ordinances often determine the outcome of disputes. His wide-ranging background allows him to interpret these forces in context, ensuring each report or testimony aligns with both industry standards and regional regulations.

​

This nationwide perspective is especially valuable for:

• Multi-state developers

• National insurance carriers

• Attorneys representing out-of-state clients

 

No matter where a case originates, Marty’s consistent professionalism, attention to detail, and commitment to ethical standards make him a trusted ally in resolving tree-related disputes fairly and efficiently.

​

​

Experience That Stands Up in Court

 

Not all Certified Arborists are qualified to serve as expert witnesses. Expert testimony demands not only technical knowledge but also the ability to communicate complex information clearly, confidently, and persuasively.

​

Marty’s 30+ expert witness testimonies reflect his exceptional skill in presenting findings that withstand scrutiny under cross-examination. His credibility has been recognized in courtrooms and hearings across the country, where his professionalism and precise documentation have helped resolve even the most contentious cases.

​

Attorneys consistently rely on his ability to deliver impartial, science-based opinions—rooted in the highest standards of arboricultural and other professional ethics.

​

​

Why Green Season Consulting is the Smart Choice

 

Whether you’re an attorney, developer, insurance adjuster, or property owner, hiring a Board Certified and Registered Arboricultural Consultant can be the deciding factor between uncertainty and resolution. Trees represent important functional, aesthetic, and environmental values or potential risks. Communicating that value or risk requires a high level of expertise that few professionals possess.

​

With more than 500 consulting cases, 30 expert witness testimonies, and work spanning 26 states, Marty Shaw of Green Season Consulting provides an unparalleled combination of experience, professionalism, and credibility. His work in Legal Circles, Tree Appraisals, Landscape Appraisals, Plant Appraisals, Investigations, and Tree Risk Assessment helps clients navigate disputes with confidence and clarity.

​

When the facts matter—and they always do—trust an expert who has dedicated his career to understanding trees, tree governance, and the truth that connects them.