United States Tree Expert Witness

​

The Role of an Expert Witness in Tree Law Across the United States

Every case involving trees eventually comes down to one thing: evidence. And when that evidence becomes technical, attorneys need someone who can interpret it — not just from a biological standpoint, but within the context of law, liability, and valuation. That’s where I come in.

​

I’m Marty Shaw, a Certified Arborist, Consultant, Author, and United States Tree Expert Witness. Over my career, I’ve consulted on more than 500 cases across 24 states and have provided expert testimony in over 30 legal proceedings. My focus is narrow but deep: I analyze tree-related evidence for attorneys, insurers, municipalities, and property owners to help clarify complex questions of causation, ownership, negligence, and value.

​

I don’t trim trees, remove them, or perform maintenance. My work exists entirely within the legal and consulting realm — translating technical arboricultural findings into clear, defensible testimony that holds up under scrutiny in courtrooms throughout the United States.

​

​

Why Attorneys Retain a United States Tree Expert Witness

Tree-related litigation often hides beneath the surface of property law, insurance disputes, and negligence claims. From California’s wildfire aftermath to hurricane damage in Florida or ice storms in the Midwest, trees frequently stand at the center of multimillion-dollar legal disputes.

​

Attorneys retain me as a United States Tree Expert Witness because cases involving trees rarely hinge on opinion — they hinge on interpretation. The visible evidence must be analyzed in a way that explains what actually happened, whether it could have been prevented, and what it’s worth in measurable terms.

​

Across the United States, I’ve supported attorneys dealing with issues such as:

• Property damage from tree failure or encroachment

• Insurance claim disputes over coverage and causation

• Wrongful removal and trespass valuation

• Construction-related injury or root damage

• Boundary disputes and tree ownership

• Negligence and duty of care litigation

• Municipal liability and code enforcement

 

Each of these requires technical understanding, professional certification, and experience with litigation. That’s why attorneys contact me — to ensure that every fact supporting their argument is backed by credible, court-ready expertise.

​

​

The Foundation of Tree Law Across the United States

Tree law in the United States is governed by state statutes, local ordinances, and common law principles. But while the legal language varies from state to state, the underlying questions remain the same:

​

Who owns the tree?
Who is responsible when it causes damage?
And what is the tree’s measurable value?

 

As a United States Tree Expert Witness, I interpret those questions using both legal and scientific frameworks. I evaluate ownership boundaries, structural condition, species value, and causation through methods accepted nationwide.

Whether the dispute involves encroachment in Georgia, negligence in Colorado, or valuation in New York, I apply the same disciplined approach to ensure the evidence supports my conclusions.

​

This consistency allows attorneys to rely on my reports in both state and federal cases. My findings adhere to professional standards recognized by courts throughout the country, including ANSI A300 (tree care standards) and the Council of Tree and Landscape Appraisers’ Guide for Plant Appraisal.

​

​

Evidence and Causation: The Heart of Every Tree Dispute

Trees can’t testify — but they do record history. A failure point tells the story of stress, decay, wind pressure, and time. My work as a United States Tree Expert Witness involves uncovering that story and turning it into usable evidence for attorneys.

​

In litigation, causation determines responsibility. Was the tree failure sudden and unforeseeable, or the result of years of neglect? Did construction or grading compromise roots, or did environmental forces alone cause collapse? I analyze the biological and environmental clues that answer those questions.

​

Attorneys rely on my conclusions to build or defend claims of negligence, trespass, or damage recovery. The ability to connect the physical evidence to legal causation often defines the success of the case. That’s why expert analysis isn’t just helpful — it’s essential.

​

​

Valuation and Economic Loss in Tree Law

When a tree is damaged or removed, its economic value becomes central to a claim. Across the United States, courts recognize that trees represent more than landscaping — they can increase property value, provide environmental benefit, and contribute to the overall use and enjoyment of the land.

​

As a United States Tree Expert Witness, I provide valuations that meet accepted national appraisal standards. My reports quantify tree value based on:

• Species and condition

• Size and maturity

• Location and contribution to property value

• Functional and aesthetic role

• Market or replacement cost

 

Attorneys use my valuations to support claims involving trespass, wrongful removal, insurance disputes, and construction damage. These appraisals aren’t hypothetical — they’re data-driven, supported by measurable metrics, and written in a format courts respect. My goal is to ensure that when you make or defend a damages claim, your numbers withstand expert review and judicial scrutiny.

​

​

Negligence and Duty of Care in United States Tree Law

Negligence claims involving trees hinge on one principle: foreseeability. A property owner or municipality may be liable if a tree failure was foreseeable — meaning signs of risk existed and were ignored. Determining foreseeability requires technical expertise.

​

When I’m retained as a United States Tree Expert Witness, I evaluate whether a duty of care existed and if that duty was breached. I document the condition of the tree, any visible signs of decay or instability, prior maintenance, and environmental conditions that contributed to the failure. My findings allow attorneys to demonstrate either that the defendant acted responsibly — or that they failed to meet a reasonable standard of care.

​

This kind of analysis frequently applies in cases involving:

• Tree failures causing injury or death

• Damage to homes, vehicles, or infrastructure

• Claims against municipalities for failure to inspect

• Commercial property disputes over maintenance obligations

 

By translating biological evidence into legally relevant conclusions, I help attorneys strengthen arguments with defensible facts instead of opinion.

​

​

The National Scope of Insurance and Tree Liability Cases

In my work as a United States Tree Expert Witness, I’m often retained in cases involving storm damage and insurance coverage. These cases can quickly grow complex because they require distinguishing between natural disasters and preventable failures.

​

Insurers often argue that a loss resulted from an “act of God,” while property owners may claim negligence or failure to act. My task is to determine whether the evidence supports either side’s position. I evaluate trunk integrity, decay progression, pruning history, and structural balance to determine the cause of failure and its preventability.

​

Because storms, wildfires, and hurricanes affect regions across the United States differently, I adapt my analysis to local environmental factors while maintaining consistent scientific methodology. This approach has made my testimony valuable in both insurance defense and plaintiff cases nationwide.

​

​

Expert Testimony: Communicating Evidence with Clarity

In every case, my job as an expert is not only to analyze the evidence but to explain it clearly. Attorneys hire me because I can articulate complex technical information in ways judges and juries understand — without diluting accuracy.

​

As a United States Tree Expert Witness, I’ve testified in cases ranging from private property disputes to major insurance litigation. My testimony covers issues such as valuation, causation, construction impact, root damage, and standard of care. I prepare for every deposition and trial with the understanding that each word may influence how the evidence is perceived.

​

Attorneys appreciate that I’m not an advocate — I’m an educator. My purpose in court is to make the facts clear, consistent, and credible. When the trier of fact understands the evidence, the case becomes stronger — regardless of which side I’m supporting.

​

​

The Legal Value of a Certified Arborist and Consultant

Certification matters in litigation. Courts across the country require that expert witnesses meet specific qualifications before offering testimony. As a Certified Arborist and consultant with a record of over 500 cases, I meet those expectations by combining professional credentials with years of forensic and legal experience.

​

Being certified through the International Society of Arboriculture (ISA) demonstrates that my analysis adheres to industry standards and that I maintain continuing education in arboricultural science. This certification, paired with my consulting and courtroom background, provides the foundation for admissible, defensible testimony in both state and federal courts throughout the United States.

​

​

Common Cases Requiring a United States Tree Expert Witness

Attorneys seek my expertise for a wide range of legal disputes, including:

• Root or limb encroachment causing property damage

• Boundary and ownership disputes

• Construction impact and root zone violations

• Wrongful removal or trespass valuation

• Insurance coverage disputes following storms or fires

• Negligence and duty of care assessments

• Government or municipal liability claims

• Environmental damage and restoration appraisals

 

Each case requires precise documentation, forensic evidence, and expert interpretation. My reports are structured to integrate seamlessly into discovery, mediation, and trial exhibits, ensuring that attorneys have the technical clarity they need at every stage of litigation.

​

​

National Standards and Consistency in Tree Law Cases

Attorneys working across multiple jurisdictions often face inconsistent regulations. United States Tree Law — though not a singular body of legislation — is unified through professional standards of evidence and expert practice. I bring that consistency to every case I handle.

​

No matter the state, my consulting work adheres to:

• ANSI A300 standards for tree care and risk assessment

• CTLA Guide for Plant Appraisal for valuation

• ISA Best Management Practices for tree inspection

• Forensic reporting standards consistent with admissible expert testimony

 

By maintaining these frameworks, I help attorneys present reliable, standardized evidence that can withstand challenge from opposing experts. Consistency is the hallmark of credible testimony, and it’s a cornerstone of my national consulting practice.

​

​

The Strategic Advantage of Early Consultation

While I’m often brought into cases after discovery begins, early engagement provides significant advantages. When retained early, I assist attorneys in identifying the critical evidence needed to establish causation, liability, and valuation before it’s lost or altered. This proactive approach ensures that the physical evidence — the tree itself — is properly documented.

​

As a United States Tree Expert Witness, I frequently collaborate with attorneys, adjusters, and investigators at the earliest stages to evaluate case strength, identify weaknesses, and prepare technical questions for deposition. The goal is simple: build your case on solid, defensible ground before you ever step into court.

​

​

The Difference a United States Tree Expert Witness Makes

Attorneys across the country rely on my consulting services for one reason — clarity. Tree-related litigation often involves data that’s highly technical and visually complex. A single misinterpretation can shift liability, reduce damages, or weaken credibility. My reports eliminate that uncertainty.

​

I don’t speculate or advocate; I explain. Every conclusion I deliver is supported by measurable evidence and professional standards. That’s why attorneys who hire me gain a competitive advantage — because every statement made under oath is backed by scientific integrity.

​

​

Working Nationwide with Attorneys and Insurers

As a United States Tree Expert Witness, my consulting practice extends across the country. I’ve worked with attorneys, insurance carriers, and municipalities from the Pacific Coast to the Southeastern states, providing consistent, objective expertise in litigation, mediation, and arbitration.

​

Whether a case involves construction impact in California, hurricane claims in Florida, ice storm failures in Tennessee, or root intrusion disputes in New York, I bring the same methodology, documentation standards, and professional rigor to each engagement.

​

My national experience means I understand regional variations — soil composition, species vulnerability, environmental stressors — that can directly influence legal outcomes. Attorneys appreciate that I combine local knowledge with nationwide consistency.

​

​

Why Attorneys Choose Marty Shaw as Their United States Tree Expert Witness

Attorneys choose me because I make their cases stronger. I’m not simply a technical resource; I’m a partner in ensuring the evidence is clear, complete, and defensible.

​

My experience as a Certified Arborist, Consultant, Author, and United States Tree Expert Witness allows me to contribute not only credibility but also strategic insight. I know how opposing experts think, how cross-examination challenges arise, and how judges interpret conflicting technical evidence.

​

Across 500+ consultations and 30+ testimonies, my role has remained consistent: provide factual, professional clarity to attorneys who need to connect biological realities to legal standards.

​

​

The Expert You Need for Tree-Related Litigation

If your case involves trees — ownership, failure, damage, or valuation — it demands expert interpretation. As a United States Tree Expert Witness, I’ve spent my career helping attorneys transform complex technical findings into clear, actionable evidence.

​

I’m Marty Shaw, Certified Arborist, Consultant, Author, and Expert Witness. I’ve consulted on more than 500 cases across 24 states and testified in over 30 legal proceedings. My work supports litigation involving tree law, appraisal, risk assessment, insurance claims, and negligence. I serve as an independent, objective expert focused on clarity, precision, and credibility.

​

When your case requires national-level expertise in United States Tree Law, contact me through Green Season Consulting. I’ll help you interpret the evidence, quantify the value, and strengthen the argument — so the facts, not assumptions, guide the outcome.